The Truth to Rumors Love Island USA‘s Amaya & Bryan Are Already Broken Up After He Was Accused of Cheating With Other Women
It’s only been a couple of weeks since the Love Island USA Season 7 finale, and there’s already rumors that the winning couple has split. But is it true? Did Amaya Papaya and Bryan break up?
Amaya and Bryan coupled up on Day 16 after failed romances with islanders like Ace Greene, Zak Srakaew, and Andreina Santos-Marte, and stayed together until the Love Island USA Season 7 finale. The couple won America’s hearts and ended up winning the $100,000 grand prize.
However, fans alleged that Bryan was cheating on Amaya after he and fellow Love Island USA contestant Marco threw a party in New York City. In a TikTok video, Bryan is seen pouring a shot into a woman’s mouth. “Bryan this is not respectful of you. Strike 1,” the video captioned in the overlay. The cheating rumors were intensified online, but what is the truth?
Did Amaya and Bryan break up after Love Island USA?
As of the writing of this article, Amaya and Bryan are likely not together. Right before the reunion aired on Aug. 25, the two had unfollowed each other on Instagram. Some TikTokers had alleged that Bryan cheated on Amaya again when a video of him talking to another woman at a restaurant surfaced. In the reunion trailer, host Andy Cohen had asked where Bryan was on the night when the cheating allegedly happened.
The couple opened up to Us Weekly about the future of their relationship on July 22, 2025. “[Amaya and I] are exclusive and taking steps to [be boyfriend and girlfriend],” Bryan said. “We care deeply about each other and we don’t want to rush things. Her happiness is very important. My happiness is very important. We got the love that we got [from fans] because we’re letting things happen naturally instead of doing stuff for the public eye, and we’re gonna continue doing that.” Amaya Papaya chimed in, “This is all the start of it. You’ll definitely be seeing me and Bry Bry.”
The couple also poked fun on the break up rumors when they posted a TikTok embracing each other. “When everyone thinks you’re over meanwhile this is us,” he captioned the video.
The two do have long-term plans together, telling Variety, “Prioritizing quality time. I want to meet other members of his family, especially his mommy. He needs to meet my siblings. Small things that are very impactful and sentimental to both of us, like going on dates or having movie nights in each other’s houses. We want to enjoy each other’s company now that cameras and mics are off,” Amaya said.
