Did Carl Cheat on Lindsay From Summer House? He Revealed The Truth

Did Carl cheat on Lindsay from Summer House?

Did Carl cheat on Lindsay from Summer House? He maintains that infidelity had nothing to do with their split. “We were engaged. We were getting married. We had a date set. They were not engaged. I didn’t cheat on Lindsay. I did not have an affair,” Carl told Rolling Stone in November 2023, comparing the frenzy to that of Tom Sandoval and Ariana Madix, who broke up after Tom’s cheating was revealed.

“I feel like our relationship was just in a different space than Sandoval’s was but at the same time, because it’s Bravo, I do think there’s a huge appetite for another scandal.” He continued: “I hope people also realize on the other side of the scandal are human beings, people who are going through something in real-time, and that’s very, very emotionally difficult. You have a lot of people weighing in about false or not truthful things going on in that situation.”

Why did Carl and Lindsay break up?

Why did Lindsay Hubbard and Carl Radke break up? Though the two have said things about the breakup, and from the sounds of it, they were dealing with problems for a while before the split because they entered couples therapy in November 2022 a few months after they were engaged; “working on foundational things,” per his interview with Rolling Stone.  

Carl revealed in an episode of Watch What Happens Live! that they were so unhappy with the state of their relationship. “I think a wedding is to celebrate your relationship, and there were foundational things that were not stable to move forward with a lifetime of marriage…” Carl said to Andy Cohen. “I mean I believe in having a stable relationship before you celebrate a wedding, and we were not in that position, I believe, to move forward with the wedding.” He continued, “I mean, I think we’re both equally responsible for our role in [the breakup].

On September 14, 2023, Lindsay Hubbard posted a statement on Instagram about how she reacted to the breakup. Here’s it in its entirety:

“I would like to start by saying thank you for allowing me the space and time to process my emotions, heal, and grieve the loss of not only my relationship, but my friendship with someone I considered my best friend for 8 years.

The last 2 weeks have been the most heartbreaking and emotional weeks of my life. My entire life and future was ripped out from underneath me and I’ve had a hard time making sense of it all – with no answers or closure on why. I feel humiliated by how it went down, and simultaneously heartbroken that it happened in the first place. My trust has been betrayed, and coming to terms with that has been difficult for me.

This was not my decision, and I do not agree with quitting a relationship (at this level) without trying everything possible first. I have spent the last couple of weeks finding my own closure and peace. I am forever grateful to my best friends who have not left my side, and have been picking up the pieces of my heart and life every day from the fallout.

I am still grieving and trying to process all that has happened, but I felt it was important to update you all. From the bottom of my heart, thank you for the love and support from my friends, family, cast mates, and all of you for carrying me through.”

Carl wrote in an email to wedding guests before her statement came out. “Words cannot possibly express how difficult the last two weeks have been for Lindsay and I” and apologized “for the confusion and lack of communication” on their split.

Carl wrote, “The fact of the matter is Lindsay is devastated and I’m crushed with how all this transpired. I graciously ask for some patience and grace to heal and recover while we navigate this extremely difficult time.”

“We were left trying to figure out how this all exactly happened before we could even have the opportunity to determine the path forward amongst ourselves,” he continued. “Sadly at this time, we are not moving forward with the wedding. The fact of the matter is Lindsay is devastated and I’m crushed with how all this transpired,” before calling the drama “a mess.”

When did Carl and Lindsay get engaged?

In August 2022, Hubbard and Radke revealed their engagement to the world through a series of snaps posted to Instagram. Their joint post was captioned, “YOOOOOOO 💍 #AThousandTimesYes,” signaling their excitement and commitment to each other. The proposal took place on the scenic Dune Beach in Southampton, New York, and the moment was made even more special as it was captured by Summer House cameras.

According to People, the elaborate proposal had been a well-kept secret. “As we got there, I told her, ‘We haven’t had time to have alone time this summer, and I wanted to do something special,’ “Radke said. “And I had the ring in a beach bag that she was carrying that I snuck in there. And she turned her back, and I figured, ‘This is my chance’ and I grabbed the ring, got down on one knee, and I turned her around and told her I wanted to spend the rest of my life with her, how happy I was, and that our love story was just beginning.”

Summer House airs on Thursday nights at 9pm ET. Here’s how to watch it for free.