The Truth to Rumors Paige DeSorbo Has a New Boyfriend After Craig Said He Was ‘Blindsided’ by Their Breakup

Joe D’Amelio (Rumored)

If pictures from the Super Bowl are to be believed, DeSorbo is now dating Joe D’Amelio. Deux Moi posted that she was “spotted getting cozy with her rumored friend.” DeSorbo had recently claimed in her Giggly Squad podcast that she was single, and had been single for a couple of months. But either things changed fast or DeSorbo was just not ready to share the new romance.

“Their Super Bowl appearance certainly suggests a spark between them,” the source added, with the post including a photo of what appears to be the two of them from the back. Meanwhile, Enty Lawer, another insider, posted a blind item a few days before the Super Bowl which seems to refer to DeSorbo. “This reality star from multiple shows is in a dilemma. If she debuts her boyfriend publicly then everyone will think she is a liar and a cheat. So, the plan is to fake date a different person for a few months and then go back to the guy she wants to be with,” it reads.

Eagle-eyed fans also caught DeSorbo’s purse in a selfie by D’Amelio and what looks like the same hotel room in a picture by DeSorbo.

DeSorbo’s Summer House co-star, Lindsay Hubbard, also maintained that DeSorbo was single and didn’t have a new boyfriend. “We filmed all summer. Then this girl launched straight into her podcast tour for four months from September through December,” she told StyleCaster at the time. “She was gone every single week. She doesn’t have time. She’s already struggling making time for her current boyfriend. She doesn’t have time to then go have another boyfriend. I don’t believe any of that. I don’t know what Austen said exactly, but Austen has a tendency to put his foot in his mouth, and I know that from personal experience. And he had an audience in front of him while he did it.

Craig Conover (2021-2024)

DeSorbo and Southern Charm star Craig Conover started dating in October of 2021 and were together until December 2024, with DeSorbo herself announcing their breakup on her podcast with Hannah Berner “Giggly Squad” on Monday, December 30^th. The two had spent Thanksgiving together, and despite the fact that she lived in New York and Conover in Charleston, SC, the relationship seemed to be going strong.

However, when she announced the breakup, DeSorbo explained, “I love him. I think he loves me. I think we will remain friends,” adding, “No one did anything. It wasn’t a bad thing. I think we both were just being really mature and saying what we want and what we didn’t want, and I think that’s extremely powerful to be able to voice how you’re feeling in real-time and what you want for your future.”

Conover addressed the breakup in January on Instagram, calling it “unexpected,” and saying, “It takes two people to be in a relationship and you can’t control other people, you can only control how you react to it.”

After rumors surfaced that DeSorbo had cheated on Conover, she set the record straight. “Let me say this here and now: I did not move on with some new guy,” she said on the February 3 “Giggly Squad” podcast episode. “I’m single. I don’t have a new boyfriend. I did not cheat — not on my ex-boyfriend.”

However, Conover did make it clear on Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen that the breakup was not mutual. “I didn’t tell her what to say [about their breakup]. I got a text and she said, ‘I’m announcing it on my podcast,’” he shared. “And then she said it was mutual, which it wasn’t, I didn’t know about it, she called me and told me.”

When Cohen asked if Conover was “blindsided” by the breakup, Conover replied, “That’s the definition of what happened. Out of nowhere, she called me and broke up with me after three years.”

He added, “We didn’t want different things, she just wanted other people and that’s fine. She didn’t want those things with me anymore and I’m not mad at her for that but I don’t like this ‘love isn’t enough’ thing because you’ll make it work.”

Andrea Denver (2021)

DeSorbo had a very quick relationship with Andrea Denver while they were filming Winter House Season 1. The two went on a few dates, but never officially became a couple and the relationship fizzled out after the show had finished filming.

Perry Rahbar (2019-2020)

DeSorbo and Rahbar started dating in 2019, and fans got many updates about their relationship on Instagram and through FaceTime calls that were caught on camera. But by October 2020, the two were done.

“I just knew in the pit of my stomach that I didn’t feel the best about myself,” DeSorbo told People about the breakup. “I didn’t feel ready to take on certain things that I know that he is so ready for. He’s 10 years older than me, so much smarter, so much more accomplished, just more mature. And I never wanted to let him down. So, I just felt like maybe this isn’t our right time.”

Carl Radke (2018)

DeSorbo had a flirtatious relationship with Radke when she joined the Summer House cast in Season 3. However, she felt like he wasn’t making enough of an effort, and that led to their relationship ending very quickly after it began.