Rumored: Robin Tunney (2015)

Pedro Pascal was rumored to be dating his The Mentalist co-star Robin Tunney in 2015. The two were photographed at different events together in 2015 and even on a sushi date in 2019.  The two met after he was cast in season six of The Mentalist as FBI agent Marcus Pike while she played the main role Teresa Lisbon.  

In September, the two attended HBO’s After Party together following the 2015 Emmys. Though there are some discrepancies in the dating rumors because Tunney became engaged to Nicky Marmet on December 25, 2012, while on vacation in Rio de Janeiro and with whom she has two children. In a Reddit AMA, one user asked what it was like working on The Mentalist and Pascal replied, “I had an amazing time with Robin Tunney, she is a new friend, and it was a really friendly set.”

Rumored: Lena Headey (2014)

Pedro Pascal was linked to Game of Thrones co-star Lena Headey in 2014. The two appeared close together and appeared in some Instagram photos of each other. One photo that sparked rumors was where Headey posted a photo of the two with the caption, “Sunshine Love.” Pascal also posted a photo of the two together in 2013 with the caption, “She make me smile goofy @iamlenaheadey” In 2015, Headey announced her pregnancy and many fans assumed that the father was The Mandalorian star. However, on 10 July 2015, Headey gave birth to a daughter named Teddy with filmmaker Dan Cadan, a childhood friend who had worked with her on his short film The Devil’s Wedding.

Maria Dizzia (90s)

Pedro Pascal is said to have dated fellow Law & Order actress Maria Dizzia in the 90s. The two starred in a Season 18 episode of Law & Order together in 2008.