After weeks of murders, banishments, and backstabbing, The Traitors Season 3 is almost over. But who will be on the cast of The Traitors Season 4? There are a few reality stars already on producers’ radar, but whether they will make it to Scotland for next season is a different story.
The Traitors, based on the Dutch series De Verraders, is a reality TV competition series following a group of contestants—some of whom are Traitors, while others are Faithfuls—as they compete for a grand prize. To win the prize, the Faithfuls must vote out all the Traitors. If the Traitors stay hidden until the end, they take the money instead.
The Traitors Season 1 premiered on Peacock in 2023 with a mix of reality TV alums and regular people. Season 2 aired in 2024 with a cast completely made of up of reality TV alumni or other celebrities. Season 3, which aired in 2025, featured the same theme for the cast. With dozens of reality stars from shows like The Real Housewives, The Bachelor, and Survivor competing on The Traitors over the years, the show has become a hotspot for the best of the best of reality television.
So who could be entering the castle next? Read on for the reality TV stars who have been approached by The Traitors so far and whether they would be interested in joining for Season 4.
Viall—best known for starring on The Bachelor, The Bachelorette, and Bachelor in Paradise—revealed in an episode of his podcast “The Viall Viles” in March 2025 that he was asked to compete in a past season of The Traitors but turned it down due to scheduling reasons. “They’ve asked me to do the show in the past. I haven’t been able to make it work,” he said. “I hope some day I can do it in the future.”
Bristow—known for her appearances on The Bachelor and The Bachelorette—revealed in an episode of her podcast “Off the Vine” in February 2025 that she was approached to star on The Traitors Season 2, but didn’t receive such an offer for Season 3. “I wish [I could do Season 4]. But nobody’s asked me,” she said. “I don’t want to be one of those desperate people like, ‘Let me on, please!’ Because then I feel like nobody wants that person who really wants to be on a show. Imagine someone being like, ‘I’m desperate to go on The Bachelor!’ They’d be like, ‘Take her off.”
Mattel—best known as a contestant on RuPaul’s Drag Race—admitted in a video on her YouTube channel in 2024 that she was asked to appear on a past season of The Traitors but turned it down as she’s done filming reality TV after serving as an executive producer on her own show, Trixie Motel.
“I got asked to do Traitors and I said, ‘No’, because I’m not gonna let people film me and do what they will with the footage! Are you out of your mind?” she said before adding that she would “go home first’ because she’s “not a good liar.” She continued, “If I was the traitor, they’d [ask me] and I’d be like, ‘No’, or start crying.”
Morgan—best known as a cast member on The Real Housewives of New York City—told Interview magazine in 2024 that she was offered a spot on Season 1 of The Traitors but didn’t end up appearing on the series. “They asked me to do it in the first season and I’m supposed to be texting back about it,” she said before revealing that she was also asked to appear on The Traitors Season 2. “They tried to get me in this season, but it was too late. I had a glitch with my emails and stuff,” she said. She continued, “Oh, I need to do it. Somebody said I should be a wild card. What does that mean?… Oh, I’ll turn the tables. I’ll dance on tables. I’ll shake it up.”
Lewis—who previously starred on Bravo’s Flipping Out—revealed on his radio show, Jeff Lewis Live, that he was approached for The Traitors but immediately turned the opportunity down. “I can’t do it. You leave for a month. I can’t leave for a month. I’ve got my house under construction, I’ve got my kid, I’ve got the radio show,” he said. “I’ll also be so unlikeable.”
